Talk:Ishikawa Rika

From Wiki.theppn

Is the discography really needed? It seems a bit redundant and unnessecary. Just my 2 cents. --Emeraldas 08:07, 10 Jun 2005 (JST)

I agree. The discography on an artist's page is for solo releases of that artist. For participations by an artist in groups there's the group list. To see what a group released follow the link.

Although I understand (I think) why this discography was created --to have an overview of all the works where Rika participated-- this is not the place. If you want to find where Rika is linked in this Wiki use the What links here link. One of the limitations of the Wiki format is that it doesn't have the dynamic view capabilities that a 'real' database offers (e.g. show all Morning Musume singles with Rika before 2003). There is already the danger of inconsistent redundant information (database designers know what I'm talking about), let's not make it worse by creating another Morning Musume/Hello Project discography here. --tiny 17:17, 10 Jun 2005 (JST)

You know, technically Charmy was a character Rika performed in Hello Morning, not sure it should redirect to Rika's page directly. DarkScorpion 09:46, 23 April 2006 (JST)